Insights · EU law

European directives in disputes between private parties: limits and consistent interpretation

In the first article of this series we saw that an individual can rely on an untransposed directive against the Administration, if certain requirements are met. But many disputes do not pit the citizen against the State, but two companies, a consumer against their supplier or an employee against their private employer. What role does European law play then?

A directive does not, by itself, bind another individual

As a general rule, a directive cannot by itself impose obligations on one individual in favour of another. This is the limit of what is known as horizontal direct effect.

That does not mean European law has no influence on such disputes. Courts must interpret national law, as far as possible, in line with the purpose of the directive. In addition, certain general principles or rights of the Union may have effect in their own right.

It is important not to confuse the two situations: the protection that derives from an autonomous European right is not the same as recognising a general horizontal effect for directives. The Association de Médiation Sociale judgment (C-176/12) shows precisely the limits of that possibility.

Consistent interpretation and its limits

Even if a provision has no direct effect, it may be decisive for interpreting Spanish legislation. This is what is known as consistent interpretation: seeking, within the possibilities offered by national law, a reading that is compatible with the directive.

This obligation has a limit: it does not allow an interpretation contra legem, that is, giving the national rule a meaning that it cannot bear.

The judgment of the Court of Justice of the European Union of 13 June 2024, delivered in joined cases C-331/22 and C-332/22, illustrates this difficulty. The Court held that, where national law does not provide adequate measures to prevent and, where appropriate, penalise the abuse arising from the use of successive fixed-term employment relationships, converting them into permanent employment relationships may constitute an adequate measure, provided that it does not involve an interpretation contra legem of national law. The judgment therefore contemplates a possible response to abuse, subject to those conditions, but it does not establish the automatic conversion of interim civil servants into career civil servants.

Two cases with effects on third parties

Permits with an environmental impact. Sometimes a claim is directed against the Administration, but its outcome also affects a private party. That does not necessarily turn the case into a dispute in which a directive is applied directly against that private party. This was the position in Wells (C-201/02). A citizen asked the British authorities to remedy the absence of an environmental impact assessment for a mining operation. Granting her request could require the activity to be halted while the assessment was carried out and, as a result, harm its owners. The Court clarified that this harm did not prevent the directive from being invoked against the authorities. The citizen was demanding that the State comply with its obligations, not that the directive directly impose an obligation on the owners of the operation. The difference is important: a directive may be used to bring a claim against the Administration, even if the consequences of that claim affect a company.

Recovery of taxes wrongly passed on. In Gabel Industria Tessile and Canavesi (C-316/22), the Court examined the recovery of an electricity tax contrary to European law that had been passed on to end consumers. The judgment maintained the limit on direct effect between individuals. But it recalled that the refund system must respect the principle of effectiveness: if recovering the amount through the supplier is impossible or excessively difficult, the consumer must be able to claim the refund directly from the State. This prevents the State’s failure to comply with a directive from leaving unprotected the person who bore the cost of the tax.

In the next instalment

Sometimes neither direct application nor consistent interpretation is enough to remedy the harm. In the last article of the series we will look at when compensation can be claimed from the State and how to approach the defence of a right granted by a directive.

← Back to Insights

Does this issue affect you?

Tell us about your project and we will help you give it legal shape, with a practical view of the Spanish and international legal landscape.

Request advice