Insights · EU law

When can a European directive be invoked against the Administration?

A European directive may grant rights that Spain has not yet correctly incorporated into its legislation. Does that mean a citizen or a company must wait for the legislator to act before they can demand them? In certain circumstances, they can rely on those rights directly against the public authorities.

This possibility derives from what is known as the direct effect of directives. Together with the primacy of European Union law, it is an important tool for defending the rights of individuals and businesses. Its application requires, however, distinguishing which provision is being invoked, against whom, and for what purpose.

Primacy and direct effect are not the same thing

The principle of primacy requires that EU law prevail, within its scope of application, over incompatible national rules. Its purpose is for European rules to be applied uniformly in all Member States.

Primacy and direct effect are, however, different concepts. The former determines which rule prevails in the event of a conflict; the latter allows a provision to be invoked before the national authorities. For that reason, primacy does not automatically turn every provision of a directive into a directly enforceable right.

When can a directive be applied directly?

Directives require Member States to achieve certain results, but they normally need to be incorporated into national law through transposition. When that incorporation fails, the State’s failure must not deprive individuals of European protection.

To rely directly on a provision against the State, three conditions must, broadly speaking, be met:

  1. The transposition deadline has expired.
  2. The State has not transposed it, or has done so incorrectly.
  3. The provision relied on is sufficiently clear, precise and unconditional.

The assessment is made provision by provision: not every provision of the same directive necessarily meets those requirements.

Against whom can it be invoked?

As a general rule, the direct effect of directives is vertical: it allows an individual to invoke a provision against the State.

The concept of the State goes beyond central government. It may cover regional and local authorities and certain bodies or entities subject to public control. It may also extend to private entities entrusted with a task in the public interest and endowed for that purpose with special powers, as the Court of Justice made clear in Farrell (C-413/15).

Therefore, the legal form of the entity does not settle the question on its own. Its relationship with the public authorities, its functions and its powers must be analysed.

The Administration cannot use it against you

The rule does not work in reverse. The State cannot rely on an untransposed directive to impose obligations on an individual by itself: this is the prohibition on what is known as inverse vertical direct effect.

The judgment of 8 October 2020 in MO v Subdelegación del Gobierno en Toledo (C-568/19) applied this rule in the field of immigration law. The Court of Justice rejected the Administration’s reliance directly on the Return Directive to order an expulsion, in the circumstances examined, thereby displacing the more favourable conditions of national legislation.

In the next instalment

Direct effect has limits when the dispute is not with the State, but with another company or another individual. In the next article we will look at what happens in those cases and how consistent interpretation works.

If an administrative action may be limiting a right that European legislation grants you, at EVENOR Abogados we can help you analyse it.

← Back to Insights

Does this issue affect you?

Tell us about your project and we will help you give it legal shape, with a practical view of the Spanish and international legal landscape.

Request advice